Select a different bill



HB 0196 - Criminal procedure; reversal on appeal when a judge expresses an opinion regarding proof in a criminal case or as to accused's guilt; change provisions

Tracking Level: Monitor
Sponsor: Reeves, Bert 34th
Last Action: 4/2/2015 - House Withdrawn, Recommitted
House Committee: JudyNC
Assigned To:
05. Superior CourtsNext Bill
06. State CourtsNext Bill

Staff Analysis of the Legislation

HB 196 amends O.C.G.A. Code Section 17-8-57, which prohibits judges,  during any phase of any criminal case, to express or intimate to the  jury the judge's opinion as to whether a fact has or has not been proved  or as to the guilt of the accused. The bill requires a party who  alleges a violation of this statute to make a contemporaneous objection,  outside of the jury's presence, and inform the court of the specific  objection and the grounds for such objection. The court may give a  curative instruction to the jury or declare a mistrial. Failure to make a  contemporaneous objection shall preclude appellate review, unless such  violation constitutes plain error which affects substantial rights of  the parties. Such plain error may be considered on appeal.

Bill Summary from the State Site - Click for the State Summary Page / Click for Current Full Text